Court rejects refrigeration efficiency action
The US Department of Energy (DOE) final rule on energy conservation standards for commercial refrigeration equipment, issued in March 2014, includes maximum daily energy consumption values as a function of either refrigerated volume or total display area for various equipment classes.
The Air Conditioning, Heating, and Refrigeration Institute (AHRI) and Midwest manufacturer Zero Zone challenged the new rule on the grounds of being “impossible” to meet, and claimed that the DOE had failed to perform all the procedural steps required in formulating the standards. The subsequent court petition filed in June 2014 was consolidated with a similar challenge from NAFEM, the North American Association of Food Equipment Manufacturers.
The US Court of Appeals for the Seventh Circuit yesterday denied the petitions in their entirety and ruled in favour of the DOE, finding that the agency acted within its authority and within reason.
Expressing his disappointment the Court’s ruling, AHRI president and CEO Stephen Yurek also questioned the Court taking nearly a year after oral argument to issue its decision.
In its petition the AHRI had argued that the DOE failed to follow its procedures and that its analysis was flawed. AHRI also raised concerns regarding DOE issuing test procedure amendments after amending efficiency standards.
“Issuing a test procedure after efficiency standards is a backwards way of handling rules, and makes it difficult for manufacturers to understand the impact of the new standards and to design equipment to comply with those standards, all while continuing to meet the needs of consumers,” said Yurek.
When the rule was issued in 2014, the AHRI argued that in the case of some of the 49 product categories covered the specified efficiency level was not at that time achieved by any models on the market. The deadline of March 27, 2017, was also as too soon for manufacturers to research, design, develop, and test new products.
Following yesterday’s ruling, Stephen Yurek said the decision provided further incentive for Congress to update the Energy Policy and Conservation Act, an over 40-year-old law that gives DOE’s its energy efficiency rulemaking authority. “Reforms are needed to provide stakeholders with an equal voice, greater certainty, and better transparency in the regulatory process,” the AHRI says in a statement.
The full ruling can be found here.
Latest news from the world of air conditioning and refrigeration
UK: Industrial refrigeration contractor Stonegrove Refrigeration has appointed Steve Gowing as design and project engineer.
UK: Javac UK, the refrigerant recovery and vacuum pump supplier, has been named as Climate Centers’ Supplier of the Year for the second year running.
UK: Ruskin Air Management has been renamed Swegon Air Management following its acquisition by the Swedish manufacturer Swegon.
SWEDEN: Heat exchanger manufacturer SWEP is to close its manufacturing plant in Tentlingen, Switzerland, moving production to factories in Slovakia and Sweden.
USA: Seven local residents are reported to be suing Honeywell after a chemical leak at its Geismar, Louisiana, plant in August.
BELGIUM: Daikin Europe’s factory in the Czech Republic has joined the group’s factory in Ostend by becoming certified to the BRE’s responsible sourcing standard.
USA: Parker Hannifin and Daikin were the big winners in a unique competition designed to raise the level of awareness of the HVACR industry both in school and government.
DENMARK: Refrigeration wholesaler Beijer Ref has merged two of its Danish companies to form Aircon Teknik A/S.