Dutch cold store firms fined €12.5m

ACM-logoNETHERLANDS: The Dutch competitions authority has fined four cold storage companies nearly €12.5m for making illegal agreements and distorting competition.

The fines were imposed by the Netherlands Authority for Consumers and Markets (ACM) in three cases on four companies. Five executives  each received personal fines, the highest of which was €144,000.

It was said that between 2006 and 2009, the companies involved – Eimskip, Kloosbeheer, Samskip and Van Bon (now H&S Coldstores) – were holding merger talks. In those talks they made arrangements about prices, exchanged competition-sensitive information, and shared customers among each other. As a result ACM says that competition in the cold-storage market had been seriously impeded.

Illegal agreements

“These companies made illegal agreements, and thus distorted competition, said ACM chairman Chris Fonteijn. “Competition is necessary for producing competitive prices, better quality, and innovation in markets. Cartels are simply not allowed. One company fully cooperated with the investigation, and will therefore see its fine reduced. During the investigations into the cold-storage market, two other companies also made promises to improve their behaviour. With the fines and these promises, we wish to promote competition in this particular market.”

The companies were served with fines between €450,000 and €9.6m.

Admission

After admitting to its mistakes and co-operating with ACM’s investigation, Kloosbeheer’s fine was reduced by 10%. In the period under investigation, Kloosbeheer was holding merger talks. Kloosbeheer admitted that it had been ‘too open too soon, during the merger talks.

Between 2006 and 2009, the companies concerned were said to have distorted competition in various ways. Anticompetitive arrangements were discovered in various emails and competition-sensitive information was frequently exchanged. There were instances of managers informing each other about the price for food storage, discussed current utilisation rates of their storage facilities, and whether or not they were looking for jobs. Sometimes they made arrangements about who would get which customer or about what price increase would be passed on. Also, arrangements were made about bids to potential clients, which meant that it was clear in advance who would get the job, says the ACM.


Latest news from the world of air conditioning and refrigeration

UK News

1st December, 2016

steve-gowing-home

Stonegrove appoints Gowing

UK: Industrial refrigeration contractor Stonegrove Refrigeration has appointed Steve Gowing as design and project engineer.

1st December, 2016

javac-award-climate-center

Javac achieves Climate Center double

UK: Javac UK, the refrigerant recovery and vacuum pump supplier, has been named as Climate Centers’ Supplier of the Year for the second year running.

28th November, 2016

kevin-munson-home

Ruskin renamed Swegon Air Management

UK: Ruskin Air Management has been renamed Swegon Air Management following its acquisition by the Swedish manufacturer Swegon.

25th November, 2016

swep-tentlingen

SWEP to close Swiss plant

SWEDEN: Heat exchanger manufacturer SWEP is to close its manufacturing plant in Tentlingen, Switzerland, moving production to factories in Slovakia and Sweden.

World News

4th December, 2016

137284

Honeywell faces action over leak

USA: Seven local residents are reported to be suing Honeywell after a chemical leak at its Geismar, Louisiana, plant in August.

3rd December, 2016

daikin-czech-rep

Daikin Plzen plant is BES 6001 certified

BELGIUM: Daikin Europe’s factory in the Czech Republic has joined the group’s factory in Ostend by becoming certified to the BRE’s responsible sourcing standard.

3rd December, 2016

young-buskirk-chairmans-awards

AHRI rises to chairman’s challenge

USA: Parker Hannifin and Daikin were the big winners in a unique competition designed to raise the level of awareness of the HVACR industry both in school and government.

3rd December, 2016

aircon-teknik

Beijer Ref merges Danish businesses

DENMARK: Refrigeration wholesaler Beijer Ref has merged two of its Danish companies to form Aircon Teknik A/S.

JOIN OUR NEWSLETTER
Leave A Comment