World News

Industry news and insights from Europe and around the World

UK News

Latest news and developments in the United Kingdom

Products

Keep up-to-date with the latest new products and technology

Features

General articles, applications and industry analysis

Iceland AHU is “tool of the trade”

UK: Refrigerated food retailer Iceland has won a Supreme Court battle to exclude an external air handling plant from the rateable value of the building.

Yesterday’s Supreme Court ruling decided that an external air handling unit serving integral cabinets at an Iceland store in Liverpool was a “tool of the trade” and should be excluded from the rateable value of the property. The decision settles a dispute dating back to 2010, and could have far reaching effects for refrigerated food retailers and others.

The Iceland property in question at 4 Penketh Drive, Liverpool, has around 80 refrigerated cabinets, all but one of the cabinets being integral units. The cabinets are by far the largest single contributor to the stores heat load. In order to handle these heat gains, a large air handling unit with a cooling capacity of approximately 85kW is located outside to the rear of the building.

In 2010, Iceland applied for a reduction on the rateable value of the property on the basis that the air handling unit used in connection with refrigerated goods were “manufacturing operations or trade processes” under the Valuation for Rating (Plant and Machinery) (England) Regulations 2000.

Plant and machinery that forms part of the property cannot normally be taken into account when calculating the property’s rateable value. However, the 2000 Regulations created an exemption for plant and machinery that could be described as part of the “tools of the trade” of the business, rather than as part of the property.

After being turned down, Iceland appealed to a valuation tribunal, which decided the issue in Iceland’s favour. That finding was then reversed by the Upper Tribunal, whose decision was upheld by the Court of Appeal. Both of these ruled that business rates should be calculated on the full value of the retail warehouse including the air handling system because it did not fall within the exemption granted to plant and machinery used in connection with “manufacturing operations or trade processes”.

Iceland finally appealed to the Supreme Court on the issue, which yesterday decided unanimously in the retailer’s favour.

Iceland argued that the Court of Appeal misunderstood the purpose of the legislation and had adopted an unduly restrictive interpretation of the exemption. The trade process was one of continuous freezing or refrigeration of goods to preserve them in an artificial state, without which they would be worthless. The air handling plant was installed to deal with the heat generated by the freezers and refrigerators and was, therefore part of that trade process and thereby excepted from rateability.

Latest News

28th March 2024

Topical talks at Bath breakfast meeting

UK: The next South West South Wales Refrigeration Society breakfast briefing will feature talks from three experienced and knowledgable speakers on varied refrigeration and air conditioning topics.
28th March 2024

CO2 compressor for multiple applications

ITALY: Frascold’s new TK HD series transcritical CO2 compressors are designed for a wide range of refrigeration and air conditioning applications, as well as high-temperature heat pumps up to 100°C.
28th March 2024

Copeland releases 50hp scroll in Asia

CHINA: US compressor manufacturer Copeland is to launch a 50hp scroll for heat pump OEMs in Asia.
27th March 2024

Daikin redesigns Perfera R32 air conditioner

BELGIUM: Daikin Europe has announced a next generation All Seasons Perfera R32 air conditioner with redesigned indoor and outdoor units, making them easy to install and use.
27th March 2024

Press fittings go large

UK: Conex Bänninger has expanded its >B< MaxiPro range of press fittings with the addition of a 1⅝in fitting.
27th March 2024

Distilling the zero carbon benefits of heat pumps

IRELAND: An Irish distiller is now producing carbon neutral whiskeys following the installation of high temperature heat pumps from Finnish manufacturer Oilon.